Today's guest is romantic suspense author Chris Redding. In any of
the romance subgenres, male-female relationships are important. But creating
realistic male characters is important for all forms of writing. (I've heard
editors and agents say that children's or teen books written by women often
have unrealistic boy characters.) Here's Chris to explore communication
differences between men and women:
This is
an excerpt from my lecture on Communication in my workshop: Show Up Naked:
Writing the Male Point of View.
Men are lecturers. They are
used to giving out information and expecting people (especially women) to
listen to what they have to say. Ever been with a guy who just went on and on?
He has no idea that you lost interest about five minutes ago.
He’s lecturing. He assumes that because you are quiet that you are interested.
Imagine your hero begin to do this and your strong heroine getting up in his
face about it. Conflict!
Often, even if the woman adds something to the conversation, the man does not
pick up on those facts. He will keep going on his own track of the
conversation. These situations can start out on an even keel, but then the man
takes over. This (and I hate to keep harping on this) is because it puts them
at a higher status. They are the information giver. They have something that
the other person supposedly wants. Women, in seeking rapport, tend to downplay
their expertise. Men are quite willing to take center stage.
But a strong heroine, especially one in a dangerous situation is less likely to
worry about rapport. She’s worried about getting out of the situation. She
isn’t going to fall back on creating connections. She wants to create an escape.
I teach CPR and I find this with a lot of the male instructors. They
automatically take over or become lead instructor. And I’m a pretty strong
personality so they don’t really get away with it.
Deborah Tannen in You Just
Don’t Understand talks about
how different conversations are with men and women in terms of what she does
for living. Specifically she talks about social functions.
My experience is that if I mention
the kind of work I do to women, they usually ask me about it. When I tell them
abut conversational style or gender differences, they offer their own
experiences to support the patterns I describe.
But when I announce my line of work to men, many give me a lecture on language
– for example, about how people, especially teenagers, misuse language
nowadays. Others challenge me, for example questioning me about my research
methods. Many others change the subject to something they know more about.
Psychologist H. M.
Leet-Pellegrini wanted to discover which was more important to determining who
would act in a “dominant” manner, those of a certain gender or those who have
expertise in a subject. She set up pairs to discuss TV violence’s affect on
children. The pairs were either two men, two women or one of each. In some
cases, one of the partners was an expert on the subject. The experts definitely
talked more, but the male experts talked more than the female experts.
Non-expert women gave more support to their partners regardless of whether that
partner was an expert or not. Men who were not experts on the subject were less
likely to give support to the women who were the expert. In fact even if a
woman was an expert she tended to give supportive statements to the non-expert
man.
When an expert man talked to a non-expert woman, he tended to control the
conversation, though if he was talking to another man, expert or not, he was
less likely to control the ending of the conversation.
In other words, when a man has expertise he isn’t challenged about it by a
woman, but will be by a man.
It all goes back to jockeying for status. To do that the man must challenge the
authority.
Chris Redding lives in New Jersey with her husband,
two kids, one dog and three rabbits. She graduated from Penn State with a degree
in Journalism. When not writing she
works for her local hospital in the Emergency Services Department. She has been
writing for thirteen years and has five books published.
What if your past comes back to haunt you?
Chelsea James, captain of the Biggin Hill First Aid Squad, has had
ten years to mend a broken heart and forget about the man who’d left her hurt
and bewildered. Ten years to get her life on track. But fate has other plans.
Fire Inspector Jake Campbell, back in town after a decade, investigates a string of arsons, only to discover they are connected to the same arsons he’d been accused of long ago. Now his past has come back to haunt him, and Chelsea is part of that past.
Together, Chelsea and Jake must join forces to defeat their mutual
enemy. Only then can they hope to rekindle the flames of passion. But before
they can do that, Chelsea must learn to trust again. Their lives could depend
on it.
Thanks for having me today.
ReplyDeletecmr
I've gotten several requests to critique stories (both MG and YA) with male MCs, written by women. They wanted to know if the MC was believable. So far I've never had a problem with the characters.
ReplyDeleteGood to know, Ken! I have a male writer friend who has complained about "boy books" that sound like they're written from a middle-aged woman's perspective. I asked him to read the first manuscript in my Haunted Series, the Ghost on the Stairs, where the narrator is a 13-year-old boy. He had a few suggestions, but basically it passed. Whew! I also had a male editor on the series. It's nice to have that confirmation that you're getting it right.
ReplyDelete